Skip to main content

"Worse than a barbarian" vs "monster parental intrusion"...performance controversy rants and raves

▲(뉴시스)

A representative of a parent organization that accused MAMAMOO member Hwasa, 28, of performing an obscene performance on stage at a university festival commented on the performance, saying, "(Hwasa's) obscene movements can have a worse effect than Barbary Man." On the other hand, the pop culture community countered that it was "excessive interference from parents who haven't even seen the performance."

On the 11th, Shin Min-hyang, head of the Student and Parental Rights Protection Alliance (Hakinyeon), said on CBS's Kim Hyun-jung's news show, "Barbary Man is punished under the Misdemeanor Punishment Act. In the case of Hwasa, a larger number of unspecified members of the public saw the performance, so in some ways, the negative impact may be greater than that of the barbarian."


Earlier, on May 12, Hwasa performed "Don't Give Me" with singer Rokko at Sungkyunkwan University in Seoul as part of the filming of tvN's "Dance Dance Wanderers. On stage, Hwasa sat with her thighs apart and choreographed licking her hands with her tongue and flicking certain body parts. Immediately afterward, the scene spread on social media in the form of a "direct-cam" video, sparking controversy for being overly sexualized. The scene was edited out of the subsequent episode of "Dance Dance Wanderers. On June 22, Hak In Yeon filed a police complaint against the scene, saying it caused sexual shame to the public.


Shin said, "Hwasa's behavior was completely out of context with the choreography of the show. These acts fall under the obscene acts prescribed in Article 245 of the Criminal Code, the performance obscenity offense," he said, explaining that he filed the complaint after seeing elementary school students watching the performance. "I was not at the university site, but the video went viral and I was forced to watch it unwillingly. The fact that the public was humiliated by the performance, and the fact that minors were allegedly present at the performance site, constitute the crime of performance obscenity." He added.


In response to the criticism that Hak In-yeon's accusation was an 'overreaction', he said, "Even if it is a performance, it should be performed according to the place and people. I don't think it should be carried out like terrorism against the majority in an unexpected place," he said, adding, "There are those who claim artistic repression, but in the name of art, is it okay to carry out any act in a space where young students are naturally expected to be?"


On the other hand, Kim Heon-sik, a pop culture critic, argued that the accusations against Hakinyeon were excessive.


"This is a case of excessive intervention in artistic freedom by the 'Monster Parents' group," he said on the same radio program. "It's basically a performance by university students, and it's not appropriate for the police to intervene because a third party, a parent organization, who was not at the performance, filed a complaint, from the point of view of artistic spirit and freedom of expression."


"It's as if the police were called in to protect their children just because they were parents in the audience," Kim said. "If the problem is that the video was spread through social media, then the responsibility of the social media platform, which is the main source of the spread, should also be mentioned, but it was left out and only Hwasa was accused."


Recently, Hwasa was investigated by the police for the accusation. On the 10th, her agency Pnation said, "Hwasa was recently summoned by the police as a defendant and investigated."


READ THE ARTICLE


READ THE KOREAN VERSION

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Japan Meteorological Agency lists Dokdo as Japanese territory on weather map for Typhoon No. 7 Lan

▲일본 기상청에 표기된 독도. 사진제공=서경덕 교수 The Japan Meteorological Agency has sparked controversy for labeling Dokdo as Japanese territory on a weather map of Typhoon No. 7. On the 16th, Seo Kyung-duk, a professor at Sungshin Women's University, sent a protest email to the Japan Meteorological Agency through social networking services (SNS), demanding that the agency correct its mistake of labeling Dokdo as Japanese land. "The Japan Meteorological Agency has always labeled Dokdo as '竹島' (Takeshima), and we have been protesting against this for three years. The biggest problem is that many Japanese netizens visit the Japan Meteorological Agency's website during typhoon and tsunami warnings, which can create a false perception of Dokdo," he said. "In this protest email, we said, 'This is a clear territorial provocation. Dokdo is an undisputed territory of the Republic of Korea under historical, geographical, and international law." Professor Seo said that not o...

‘엠카 인 프랑스’서 불거진 인종차별 논란…현장 증언 들어보니

  ▲(사진제공=CJ ENM) 프랑스 파리에서 열린 K팝 공연 ‘엠카운트다운 인 프랑스’가 인종차별 논란에 휩싸였다. 현장 보안요원들이 동양인들만 골라 엄격히 단속했다는 주장이 제기된 데 따른 것이다. 15일(현지시간) CJ ENM의 음악 프로그램 ‘엠카운트다운’이 프랑스 파리 라데팡스 아레나에서 개최됐다. 이날 공연에는 약 2만2000여 명의 관객들이 모인 가운데 NCT드림, 샤이니 태민, 몬스타엑스 셔누·형원, 에이티즈, 싸이 등이 무대를 꾸몄다. CJ ENM측은 사전에 “파리 라데팡스 아레나는 전문가용 카메라 반입이 금지된 공연장”이라고 밝힌 바 있다. 이에 현장에서는 카메라 등의 소지품 검사가 진행됐다. 그런데 현장 요원들이 유럽인들도 카메라를 소지하고 카메라로 무대를 촬영했음에도 동양인들만 엄격하게 단속했다는 현장 증언이 나왔다. 증언에 따르면 현장 요원들은 동양인들의 카메라를 압수하거나 가방을 뒤지는 행위도 서슴지 않았다. 논란이 지속되자 CJ ENM 측은 “반입 금지 물품을 모니터링하는 과정에서 과잉 진압이 있었는지 사실 관계 확인중”이라고 밝혔다. 한편, K팝 콘서트에서 인종차별 의혹이 발생한 것은 이번이 처음은 아니다. 2021년 말에 있었던 방탄소년단의 LA콘서트에서 한국팬들은 카메라를 들고 가수를 찍었다는 이유로 현지 팬들에게 폭행을 당하기도 했다.

Mbappe angry at Japanese reporter's sarcasm of Lee Kang-in?

   ▲출처=유튜브 캡처 A video of Kylian Mbappe (25, Paris Saint-Germain) wrapping his arms around Lee Kang-in (22, Mallorca) in response to a sarcastic question from a Japanese journalist has been revealed to be a fake video manipulated by artificial intelligence (AI). It was a real press conference, but it was a video of Mbappe answering questions about his contract at the Euro 2020 press conference two years ago. Instead of the player's voice asking the question, a 'fake question voice' was created and edited. On the 15th of last month, a YouTube channel posted a video titled 'Marketing for Lee Kang-in, right? Mbappe's reaction to a Japanese reporter's question'. A Japanese journalist is heard asking in English during a press conference, "I heard that a South Korean player named Lee Kang-in is coming to Paris Saint-Germain (PSG). Do you think it's just a marketing move, and what do other Japanese players think?" Mbappe shakes his head. Mbappe shakes ...